Backlash over 'completely unacceptable' bus replacement plan in Kilkenny


Proposed route replacement will not directly serve Dublin and has been rejected by campaign group in Kilkenny
Kilkenny campaigners are feeling ‘completely let down’ by a planned replacement bus service that will still leave some local communities without a direct link to Dublin once Expressway Route 4 is withdrawn this Sunday.
In recent days, details of the proposed replacement service for the Waterford - Dublin Airport service emerged and prompted a fresh wave of backlash from campaigners and public representatives.
They argue the new arrangement falls far short of what local communities require and were promised.
The National Transport Authority (NTA) has issued a statement confirming that a new Public Service Obligation route (numbered 365) is due to begin operating from Sunday, May 24.
This route will operate between Waterford and Carlow (via Kilkenny) following Expressway’s decision to withdraw Route 4.
However, passengers from Kilkenny intending on travelling on to Dublin will now be forced to change services in Carlow.
The result is the end of the direct bus connection that many Kilkenny commuters have relied on for years.
We are fully aware of the announcement [from the NTA] issued to public representatives, and reject it outright
The NTA contends that the replacement service is intended “to maintain public transport connectivity on this corridor” after Expressway informed the authority that Route 4 would cease operating.
The authority said the new service is expected to run four times daily in each direction between Waterford and Carlow and would “serve more towns and villages along the route than the current Route 4.”
But campaigners behind the 4 Bus 4 Us campaign say the proposal does not address the core issue facing passengers. That being the loss of a direct bus route to Dublin.
In an email circulated to public representatives and transport officials, the group stated that they “reject it outright”.
“We are fully aware of the announcement issued to public representatives, and reject it outright,” the email stated.
A petition launched to save the existing service gathered thousands of signatures in recent weeks, particularly in communities along the route including Thomastown, Ballyhale and Mullinavat.
Campaigners are now warning that requiring passengers to change buses in Carlow would significantly increase already lengthy journey times.
“To include other towns and villages on a route to Carlow is undoubtedly welcome by those villages, however, it further extends the journey time even above that extra time that will occur in service requiring an interconnection,” the group wrote.
The group further argued that the proposed replacement service should instead operate ‘as an additional and separate link service’, rather than replacing the existing direct route.
Sinn Féin TD Natasha Newsome Drennan also called on the Minister for Transport to intervene and ensure Route 4 remains operational until a full replacement is introduced.
She said the service was “far more than an express link between Waterford and Dublin” and is “a vital link for rural communities across Carlow and Kilkenny.”
The level of dependency on this service cannot be overstated
“From students travelling to college to older people getting to medical appointments, the level of dependency on this service cannot be overstated,” Deputy Newsome Drennan added.
“This route is used by workers, students, and the elderly. Withdrawing the service without any alternative lined up will leave a huge number of people with no transport to get to college, work or vital appointments.”
Senator Patricia Stephenson also criticised the proposed changes, saying communities in Kilkenny and Carlow feel “completely let down”.
“People rely on this route every day to get to work, college, hospital appointments and childcare,” she said.
“Instead of reassurance, communities are facing confusion, reduced services and fears of longer journey times and additional costs.”
Leas-Cheann Comhairle and Fianna Fáil TD John McGuinness also said that the proposed replacement for the Expressway Route 4 service is “simply not good enough” and represents yet another blow to rural Ireland and those who depend on reliable public transport connections.
“I will be pressing the Minister for Transport, Darragh O'Brien, for immediate clarity on this matter,” he said.
Simply telling rural communities to make their own onward arrangements to Dublin is unacceptable
“People deserve answers and they deserve certainty. Simply telling rural communities to make their own onward arrangements to Dublin is unacceptable.”
He said the lack of certainty surrounding the replacement service was “completely unacceptable”.
“This decision ignores the reality of life in rural Ireland,” he continued.
“People relied on this direct route to access Dublin City, Dublin Airport, hospitals, education and employment. Businesses and tourism operators also depend on these connections.
“Removing the direct service and forcing passengers to change buses in Carlow creates uncertainty, delays and genuine accessibility concerns, particularly for older people and people with disabilities.”
He also expressed concern that the proposed replacement service would operate just four times daily in each direction, a significant reduction in frequency.
“People do not use irregular services,” he said. “Reducing the frequency of buses while also extending the number of stops risks creating a slower and less reliable service overall. This undermines public confidence in public transport and further isolates rural communities.”
