16 Aug 2022

ICMSA say increased ask on emissions from farmers moves ‘Difficult’ to ‘Impossible’


Emmisions reduction plan sells out farming families.

IFA: Agriculture sectoral emissions ceiling is a potentially devastating blow for Irish farming

Reduced emissions targets from livestock present a challenge to farmers

Responding to the announcement of a 25% emissions reduction for agriculture, Pat McCormack, the President of the ICMSA, the state’s specialist dairy farmer organisation, said that the Government’s decision would have wholly negative and predictable economic, social and demographic consequences for the massive areas of the state that depended on farming and food production and represented a ‘sell-out’ of our family farm model. Mr McCormack said that farmers and the communities they formed and which depended upon them, were not interested in hearing any more platitudes from politicians and groups who professed to appreciate the dilemma faced by farming communities but who cheerfully signed-off on policy that ‘at a stroke’ made whole classes of farms unviable.  


It was now clear that faced with the choice of doing anything that impinged upon more favoured sectors – like aviation - or undermining our irreplaceable family farm system, those same politicians – with a few notable exceptions – were happy to sacrifice the one sector in which Ireland enjoyed a unique natural benefit, global reputation, and which had been the one and only economic sector left working after the crash of a decade ago.


Mr McCormack said that the decision to go past 22% to 25% represented much more than ‘just’ an additional three percent.  The original target was going to be very difficult but at least warranted an effort. Pushing that to 25% reduction over an eight-year timeframe now moved policy from ‘difficult’ to ‘impossible’ and actually meant that the policy was now literally incredible in that it was not credible or possible to have confidence in.


“ICMSA has repeatedly stressed that if we are to move forwards together towards the new low-emissions farming and primary food production now set as policy, then the ambitions and targets must be possible and achievable.  If the historic process and transition is to win the confidence that will be necessary for it to succeed, then it simply must be realistic.  If it is not realistic – and 25% is not realistic – then the whole process loses all momentum, trust and confidence”, said Mr McCormack.


The ICMSA President concluded by noting that while today’s decision will be presented as a win for the extreme environmental element in Government, it would transpire to be a PR stunt and pointless over-reach that would inflict incalculable harm to long-term ambitions for lower emissions and sustainability.  


“The Government has badly let down family farms and their communities and we won’t be fobbed off by vague promises of future income streams. Our livestock industry - both dairy and beef - is the lifeblood of rural Ireland and Minister McConalogue and the three party leaders of the coalition have struck it at its very heart today” concluded Mr McCormack.

To continue reading this article for FREE,
please kindly register and/or log in.

Registration is absolutely 100% FREE and will help us personalise your experience on our sites. You can also sign up to our carefully curated newsletter(s) to keep up to date with your latest local news!

Register / Login

Buy the e-paper of the Donegal Democrat, Donegal People's Press, Donegal Post and Inish Times here for instant access to Donegal's premier news titles.

Keep up with the latest news from Donegal with our daily newsletter featuring the most important stories of the day delivered to your inbox every evening at 5pm.