Concerns raised over ‘cherry picking’ of Kilkenny public meetings


Kilkenny councillors raised concerns over consistency in public consultation events and planning processes at the most recent Piltown Municipal District meeting
A number of councillors in south Kilkenny have raised concerns over the holding of non-statutory public consultation events for certain projects but not others.
The issue arose at the most recent meeting of Piltown Municipal District during a discussion on the proposed relocation of a bus stop in Glenmore village.
Cllr Fidelis Doherty questioned the consistency of the approach to projects, raising concerns about ‘cherry picking what to do a public event for’ and the unfairness of other projects ‘not being given the same opportunity’.
She questioned why some proposals were being afforded additional opportunities for public engagement while others were progressing without similar events being organised.
While members of the public can make submissions as part of consultation processes, concerns were raised about whether this offers the same opportunity for engagement as an in-person event, where residents can ask questions and discuss proposals directly.
Cllr Tomás Breathnach echoed Cllr Doherty’s concerns, warning that ‘people will say that we’re inconsistent’ in how such matters are handled.
He suggested that the approach warranted further consideration, particularly when deciding which projects should be brought before the public for additional discussion.
Cllr Breathnach added that although some proposals do not require a public information event by law, it often ‘behoves us as a council’ to organise one regardless.
