High Court rejects challenge to Kilkenny wind farm permission


The project, being developed by Springfield Renewables Ltd, is proposed for Castlebanny, near Mullinavat, County Kilkenny
A High Court bid to overturn planning permission for the proposed Castlebanny wind farm in County Kilkenny has failed after the court refused to quash the permission for the 21-turbine development.
Mr Justice Richard Humphreys refused the application by Save the South Leinster Way and Tara Heavey, although the court did find in their favour on separate environmental-law issues concerning conservation objectives for protected species.
The ruling, delivered last Friday (October 2), is the latest development in a legal battle over the proposed wind farm which has been before the courts for almost four years.
The project, being developed by Springfield Renewables Ltd, is proposed for Castlebanny, near Mullinavat, and would comprise 21 turbines and associated infrastructure.
While the High Court found in favour of the applicants on environmental issues concerning conservation objectives for the kingfisher and freshwater pearl mussel, the judge concluded that the errors did not justify cancelling the project's planning permission.
PLANNING BACKGROUND
An Bord Pleanála, now An Coimisiún Pleanála, granted permission for the Castlebanny development in September 2022.
Save the South Leinster Way and Ms Heavey subsequently launched judicial review proceedings.
Their challenge initially ran into difficulty when the High Court ruled in 2023 that the proceedings were out of time. The statutory eight-week period had expired on Sunday, November 20, 2022, with the application lodged the following day when the court offices reopened.
The Supreme Court overturned that decision in December 2024, finding the application had been made within time, and remitted the case to the High Court.
LOCAL OPPOSITION
The development attracted considerable local opposition during the planning process.
Among those who made submissions opposing the project was Kilkenny hurling great and current county senior manager Henry Shefflin, who previously raised concerns over its potential impact on residential amenity, the landscape and the South Leinster Way.
The latest High Court ruling means the 2022 planning permission remains in place.
