‘Insulting’ - Kilkenny councillors hit back at online criticism of Waterford Road project


Kilkenny councillors have defended the Waterford Road project against 'insulting' online criticism, with some calling on the public to engage proactively with their issues and familiarise themselves with the project's details.
Kilkenny councillors have hit back at criticism of the ongoing Waterford Road Active Travel works, with one declaring that ‘name-calling of staff’ at Kilkenny County Council is unacceptable and another claiming that people are quick to criticise projects without engaging in public consultations.
The project forms part of the wider Active Travel Programme for Kilkenny City and is one of the key radial routes into the city centre.
The current stage of the works will result in pedestrian and cyclist friendly roundabouts with raised pedestrian crossings on each arm of the roundabout, according to the council.
The roundabouts will have single lane entries which are the appropriate design for urban areas for road safety and this roundabout type can accommodate up to 25,000 vehicles per day, significantly greater than the capacity demand at this location.
The council have also taken feedback from residents on board throughout the works, implementing some minor tweaks including adjusting the kerb lines at the entrance to the Cashel Downs estate and at the junction of the Bohernatounish Road junction with the Waterford Road.
Kilkenny County Council also asserted that the scheme has been peer-reviewed by the National Transport Authority and other consultants.
Cllr Maria Dollard of the Green Party called on the public to raise concerns in an appropriate fashion with Kilkenny County Council when speaking at November’s meeting of the Kilkenny City Municipal District.
“I would ask the public if they have an issue to lift the phone, ask one of their councillors, or use the council email if they wish to comment.
"Name-calling of staff in Kilkenny County Council is not acceptable to me, and I don’t think it should be acceptable to anybody. People are just trying to do their job; there are highly qualified people working in the county council who know a lot more about all of this stuff than any of us as councillors,” Cllr Dollard remarked.
“Name-calling is unacceptable, and I would ask the public to engage proactively with their issues,” she said.
“The public have an onus to familiarise themselves with things that are happening in their own area.”
The former Deputy Mayor of Kilkenny City stressed the public should get involved in public consultation processes from the beginning.
“Look at it now and not in three/four years, saying, ‘we didn’t know’.”
Cllr Sean Ó hArgain expressed a similar sentiment, voicing his support for the works.
“Some of the stuff that is being said online is insulting to our staff,” he said.
The Labour Party councillor also praised the public consultation process put in place by Kilkenny County Council, criticising those who chose not to take part.
“People don’t engage until diggers appear on site,” he claimed.
“This project was designed by one of the largest road consultancies, who have a very strong record in delivering on projects like this,” Cllr Ó hArgain noted, arguing some of the negative commentary has been over the top.
“People are obsessed when we widen footpaths, and they’re also obsessed, let's be blunt about it, a lot of people see no reason to put cycle paths in at all or to put in new cycle paths.
“I was cycling that road every day for 18 years going to school in the Gaeilscoil while going across town, and those paths were difficult to negotiate.
“Your heart would be in your mouth on the old cycle lane because there was no protection. Now, it’s such a much more pleasurable experience than it was. On the day of the public service strikes, I spoke to some of the teachers, and far from what some other people are saying, they’re absolutely delighted with the improvements in safety,” he continued.
“It really is frustrating when people don’t give roadworks the time to finish and get done.”
Also addressing the meeting, Independent Cllr Eugene McGuinness extended his broad support for the project but acknowledged the public’s impatience and frustration.
“I appreciate that with the works on the Waterford Road, we should wait until they’re finished; there’s no doubt about that,” Cllr McGuinness said.
“What frustrates the public is if we start making adjustments. We have a very professional team, but with all of that professionalism and all of our consultants, if we made an error in the beginning and now we can see it, sometimes that does happen,” he said.
“The public aren’t very forgiving,” he added, citing the ongoing dissatisfaction over traffic flow at Blackquarry Hill, commenting, “the public barrel it all into one.”
In response, Senior Engineer with Kilkenny County Council Stan Cullen said the council is not afraid of making adjustments if they are feasible and provide a noticeable improvement for staff on site.
Meanwhile, the council addressed the matter of large vehicles trying to use the route on a statement via their website.
“Vehicle tracking has been carried out, taking into account the turning requirements of larger vehicles,” a spokesperson for the council said in a statement on their website.
“However, Kilkenny County Council is continuing to monitor the scheme throughout the build, and we are engaging with drivers of delivery vehicles and bus companies in particular and, where necessary, minor adjustments will be made.
“As always, designs may need adjustment on the ground and based on localised constraints and patterns of human behaviour,” they added.
“The purpose of this scheme is to improve the walking and cycling facilities on the Waterford Road.
“This is to ensure that commuters using this route and students travelling to the five schools in the immediate vicinity have safe, viable, alternative modes of transport.
“The benefits will extend to residents in the locality on completion,” the spokesperson added.
“We apologise for the inconvenience and thank the public for their understanding during the works.”
The programme of works is scheduled to continue for the next four to five months.
